Research Article
Performance and Robustness of Covariance Matrix Equality Tests under High-Dimensional Covariance Structures
Abstract
When the dimension is close to or above the number of observations, classical tests for equal covariance matrices cannot be used, and the behaviour of their high-dimensional alternatives may change with the covariance structure. We examine how well three such procedures, the Srivastava–Yanagihara (SY), Ahmad (AHM), and Qayed–Han (QH) tests, hold the nominal level and how often they detect unequal covariance matrices. Monte Carlo simulations with 5,000 replications were conducted for three multivariate normal populations with sample sizes from 10 to 160 and dimensions equal to or larger than the sample size, under first-order autoregressive (AR(1)), banded Toeplitz (BTOEP), and simple diagonal (SIM) covariance structures. QH kept its empirical Type I error rate between 0.041 and 0.059 in all settings, and SY stayed inside Bradley's interval in all but one setting, whereas AHM was liberal for sample sizes of 20 or less, with rates up to 0.104. SY was the most powerful test in most AR(1) and SIM settings, while QH was the most powerful under BTOEP, with power of at least 0.91 even for samples of size 10. Because QH depends on the data only through the sum of the variables and is equivalent to Bartlett's test applied to that sum, it has high power when the variance of this sum differs between populations but only trivial power, equal to its size, against alternatives that leave it unchanged. SY is therefore recommended as the primary test when the covariance structure is unknown, with QH as a complementary test.
How to Cite
S. Wasinrat, B. Choopradit, Performance and Robustness of Covariance Matrix Equality Tests under High-Dimensional Covariance Structures, Int. J. Anal. Appl. 24 (2026), 382. https://doi.org/10.28924/2291-8639-24-2026-382
BibTeX
@article{Wasinrat2026,
author = {Wasinrat, Sirithip and Choopradit, Boonyarit},
title = {Performance and Robustness of Covariance Matrix Equality Tests under High-Dimensional Covariance Structures},
journal = {Int. J. Anal. Appl.},
volume = {24},
year = {2026},
pages = {382},
doi = {10.28924/2291-8639-24-2026-382}
}